Rule 40.Assignment of cases
Group 6: Trials · Last amended April 28, 2015 · Last verified July 13, 2026
Full Text of Rule 40
Amendment History
Adopted May 5, 1967, effective July 1, 1967; amended, effective Oct. 19, 1999; amended, effective April 28, 2015.
Plain-English Summary
Once the pleadings close, a case does not try itself, someone has to put it on the court's calendar. Rule 40 lays out how. Either party can serve a notice of trial on the opposing side at least three days before the court's next day for setting causes, and then file a note of issue with the clerk at least five days before that setting day. The note of issue has to identify the case, name the attorneys, and state when the last pleading was served, and the clerk enters the case on the trial docket by date. An issue of law raised on the pleadings follows the same pattern for the motion docket, with its own five-day notice.
A case that reaches the docket but is not tried or argued at its scheduled time does not fall off the calendar. It stays there from session to session, or from law day to law day, until it is finally resolved or struck by the court. Superior courts have flexibility in how they schedule cases for trial, they can set them without a request from the parties, on a party's request with notice to the others, or by whatever other method the court finds workable. Where preferences matter, criminal cases come ahead of civil cases, and civil cases involving a confined defendant or witness come ahead of the rest.
Once set and called, a case gets tried or dismissed unless there is good cause for a continuance. A continuance sought for missing evidence needs an affidavit showing why the evidence matters, what efforts were made to get it, and the name and address of the witness who would supply it; the court can also require the moving party to state under oath what the evidence would show, and if the other side admits that evidence would be given as described, the continuance can be denied. Finally, the rule sets firm deadlines for a motion to disqualify the assigned judge: the motion and affidavit have to be filed at least thirty days before trial when a judge has been pre-assigned, but if the case is reassigned to a different judge less than forty days before trial, the affected party gets ten days from that reassignment to move, unless that party already used its one opportunity to move for a change of judge.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between a notice of trial and a note of issue?
The notice of trial goes to the opposing party, announcing that a case will be brought on for trial or argument. The note of issue is filed with the clerk, identifying the case, the attorneys, and the date of the last pleading, and it is what triggers the clerk to place the case on the docket.
How much advance notice does a notice of trial require?
At least three days before the court's next day for setting causes for trial. The note of issue itself must then be filed with the clerk at least five days before that setting day.
What happens to a case that is on the docket but is not reached at its scheduled time?
It is not removed. The case stays on the docket from session to session, or from law day to law day, until it is finally resolved or the court strikes it.
What cases get scheduling preference over ordinary civil cases?
Criminal cases are preferred over civil cases, and a civil case where the defendant or a witness is held in confinement is preferred over other civil cases, unless a statute directs otherwise.
What must a party show to get a trial continuance for missing evidence?
An affidavit establishing that the evidence is material, that the party used due diligence to obtain it, and identifying the witness by name and address. The court can require the moving party to state under affidavit what the evidence would show, and if the opposing party admits the evidence would be given as stated, the court may deny the continuance.
How soon before trial must a motion to disqualify the assigned judge be filed?
At least thirty days before trial if the judge was pre-assigned. If the case is reassigned to a different judge less than forty days before trial, the party gets ten days from the reassignment to move, unless that party already made a change-of-judge motion in the case.